The evidence / Question bank

44 questions.
Eleven real hiring needs.

Four question types examine the core need, alternative wording, public evidence and a practical constraint. The original prompts remain unchanged.

S01 / First global payroll leader

S01-A Core hiring need

We are a UK-headquartered company expanding across Europe and North America. We need our first Head of Global Payroll, based in the UK, to take ownership of multi-country payroll. Which recruitment firms should we speak to?

Read its eight answers
S01-B Alternative wording

Who are the best recruiters for our first global payroll lead? We are based in the UK and growing in Europe and North America, and the hire will be UK-based.

Read its eight answers
S01-C Evidence and fit

We need a UK-based Head of Global Payroll for our expansion across Europe and North America. Which recruitment firms can help us define the role as well as find candidates, and what public evidence supports their experience?

Read its eight answers
S01-D Practical constraint

Our CFO wants advice on the scope, salary and candidate market for a first UK-based global payroll leadership appointment covering Europe and North America. Which specialist recruiters can help shape the brief and then run the search?

Read its eight answers

S02 / Confidential leadership replacement

S02-A Core hiring need

We need to confidentially replace our UK-based Global Payroll Director. We cannot advertise the vacancy or alert the current team. Which recruitment firms should we approach for a discreet senior payroll search?

Read its eight answers
S02-B Alternative wording

Who can headhunt a Global Payroll Director in the UK without advertising the role? This is a confidential replacement.

Read its eight answers
S02-C Evidence and fit

For a confidential replacement of a UK-based Global Payroll Director, which specialist search firms would you shortlist, and what should we verify about their confidentiality process, conflicts and access to senior candidates?

Read its eight answers
S02-D Practical constraint

We are selecting a retained search partner for a confidential replacement of a UK-based Global Payroll Director. Which firms should we compare, and what would you ask them before allowing approaches to candidates?

Read its eight answers

S03 / US employer hires a US Payroll Director

S03-A Core hiring need

We are a US employer hiring a US-based Payroll Director to lead our payroll function. Which recruiting firms should we speak to?

Read its eight answers
S03-B Alternative wording

Who recruits Payroll Directors in the US? We need someone based in the US to lead our payroll team.

Read its eight answers
S03-C Evidence and fit

Which recruiting firms would you shortlist for a US-based Payroll Director responsible for our US payroll, and what public evidence supports their experience with this kind of hire?

Read its eight answers
S03-D Practical constraint

Our US HR team will handle interviews, but we need a recruiting partner to find candidates for a US-based Payroll Director. Which firms should we consider?

Read its eight answers

S04 / Payroll systems transformation

S04-A Core hiring need

We are a UK employer replacing fragmented payroll systems across the UK and Europe. We need a UK-based Payroll Transformation Director who can lead the programme and work with HR, finance and technology teams. Which recruitment firms specialise in this kind of hire?

Read its eight answers
S04-B Alternative wording

Who recruits senior payroll change leaders in the UK? We need someone to lead a multi-country payroll system implementation, not just run monthly payroll.

Read its eight answers
S04-C Evidence and fit

Which UK recruitment firms should we consider for a Payroll Transformation Director leading a UK and European systems programme? What evidence should we request of their experience recruiting leaders across payroll operations, HR systems integration and change management?

Read its eight answers
S04-D Practical constraint

Which recruitment firms can help us hire a UK-based Payroll Transformation Director with experience keeping payroll running while moving UK and European operations onto new systems? We need a senior programme owner who can work across HR, finance and IT.

Read its eight answers

S05 / Post-acquisition payroll integration

S05-A Core hiring need

We are a UK-based, private-equity-backed group that has acquired businesses across the UK and Europe. We need a UK-based Group Payroll Director to integrate payroll teams, providers and controls. Which recruitment firms should we shortlist?

Read its eight answers
S05-B Alternative wording

Which recruiters can find a Group Payroll Director for a UK buy-and-build business? We need someone who has integrated payroll after acquisitions in the UK and Europe.

Read its eight answers
S05-C Evidence and fit

For a UK-based Group Payroll Director appointment after several UK and European acquisitions, which specialist recruiters would you approach, and what would demonstrate that they understand payroll integration rather than general finance hiring?

Read its eight answers
S05-D Practical constraint

Following several UK and European acquisitions, our UK group CFO wants one permanent Group Payroll Director to own the integration. Which recruitment agencies have a relevant senior payroll specialism, and which would you contact first?

Read its eight answers

S06 / Leadership after control failures

S06-A Core hiring need

Our UK-headquartered business has recurring payroll errors across several countries, and a review has found weak controls and unclear ownership. We need to hire a permanent Global Payroll Director in the UK to rebuild the function. Which recruiters should we speak to?

Read its eight answers
S06-B Alternative wording

Who can recruit a UK-based global payroll leader to sort out repeated pay errors and weak controls? We need a permanent director, rather than a payroll outsourcing provider.

Read its eight answers
S06-C Evidence and fit

Which recruitment firms would you shortlist for a UK-based Global Payroll Director who can rebuild controls after repeated multi-country payroll failures? What should we ask them about how they assess governance, vendor management and senior stakeholder skills?

Read its eight answers
S06-D Practical constraint

Our country payroll teams will stay in place, but we need a permanent UK-based Global Payroll Director to take accountability for controls and recurring payroll failures. Which search firms should our CFO and CHRO consider for that leadership appointment?

Read its eight answers

S07 / UK Payroll Manager replacement

S07-A Core hiring need

Our Payroll Manager has resigned. We are a medium-sized UK employer and need a permanent replacement to run our UK payroll. Which recruitment agencies should we speak to?

Read its eight answers
S07-B Alternative wording

Which recruiters can help a medium-sized UK business replace a Payroll Manager who is leaving? We need someone to take over the day-to-day UK payroll work on a permanent basis.

Read its eight answers
S07-C Evidence and fit

We need to replace our Payroll Manager at a medium-sized UK company. Which recruitment agencies would you shortlist for this permanent UK payroll role, and what public evidence supports their relevant experience?

Read its eight answers
S07-D Practical constraint

Our Payroll Manager has handed in their notice at our medium-sized UK business. We need an agency to find a permanent replacement who can run UK payroll and complete a handover before the current manager leaves. Which agencies should we approach?

Read its eight answers

S08 / US parent appoints a UK EMEA leader

S08-A Core hiring need

We are a US-headquartered multinational hiring a Head of EMEA Payroll based in the UK. The person will manage payroll across several European countries and report to our US payroll leadership. Which recruitment firms should we approach?

Read its eight answers
S08-B Alternative wording

Which recruiters can help a US company hire a UK-based EMEA payroll head? We need European payroll leadership experience and someone comfortable working with a US headquarters.

Read its eight answers
S08-C Evidence and fit

For a US multinational hiring a Head of EMEA Payroll in the UK, which recruitment firms would you shortlist? Separate evidence of UK and European payroll leadership hiring from simply having a US office or an international website.

Read its eight answers
S08-D Practical constraint

Our US payroll leadership and UK talent team need a recruitment partner for a UK-based Head of EMEA Payroll. Which firms would you consider for a search requiring European payroll leadership and coordination with US stakeholders?

Read its eight answers

S09 / Payroll provider transition

S09-A Core hiring need

We are a Manchester-based employer changing payroll providers across the UK and Europe. We need a permanent Head of Payroll, hybrid in Manchester, to own supplier governance and the transition. Which recruitment firms should we approach for this senior hire?

Read its eight answers
S09-B Alternative wording

Which recruiters can find a Head of Payroll for a hybrid role in Manchester overseeing UK and European payroll suppliers? We are changing providers and need an experienced permanent leader.

Read its eight answers
S09-C Evidence and fit

For a Manchester-based Head of Payroll responsible for a UK and European provider transition, which recruitment firms would you shortlist, and what evidence supports their ability to find leaders with vendor-governance experience?

Read its eight answers
S09-D Practical constraint

Which specialist recruitment firms could help our Manchester finance team hire a permanent Head of Payroll to manage UK and European payroll providers? The role is hybrid in Manchester and needs supplier oversight and service-transition experience.

Read its eight answers

S10 / Interim cover and permanent succession

S10-A Core hiring need

Our UK-based Global Head of Payroll is leaving before we can make a permanent replacement. We need an interim senior payroll leader for six months and support with the permanent search. Which specialist recruitment firms should we contact?

Read its eight answers
S10-B Alternative wording

Who can find an interim Global Payroll Director in the UK while we recruit the permanent head? We need leadership cover for six months, not temporary payroll processing staff.

Read its eight answers
S10-C Evidence and fit

Which recruitment firms should we consider for six-month interim Global Payroll Director cover in the UK alongside a permanent leadership search? What should we verify about director-level availability, relevant multi-country experience and the handover between the two hires?

Read its eight answers
S10-D Practical constraint

Our CFO needs six months of UK-based global payroll leadership cover, while our talent team recruits the permanent head. Which recruitment partners could handle both senior briefs and help us plan a workable handover?

Read its eight answers

S11 / Small UK team adds a Senior Payroll Specialist

S11-A Core hiring need

Our business is growing and our small UK payroll team needs another Senior Payroll Specialist to share the workload. Which recruitment agencies should we speak to for a permanent hire?

Read its eight answers
S11-B Alternative wording

We need to add an experienced Senior Payroll Specialist to a small team processing UK payroll. Which recruiters are worth speaking to as our business grows?

Read its eight answers
S11-C Evidence and fit

Which recruitment agencies would you shortlist for a permanent Senior Payroll Specialist joining a small, growing UK payroll team, and what public evidence supports their experience with hands-on payroll hires?

Read its eight answers
S11-D Practical constraint

Our UK payroll workload has grown, so we are adding a permanent Senior Payroll Specialist to our existing small team. We need someone confident with end-to-end UK payroll and day-to-day queries. Which recruitment agencies can help?

Read its eight answers