Six detailed comparisons
Who else enters
the shortlist?
Compare observed recommendation coverage and the evidence each firm makes available to employers. UK and US results need separate reading.
Counts describe these selected hiring questions, not market share or service quality. Each answer can recommend several firms.
Detailed comparison
Portfolio Payroll
Payroll specialism with separate buying routes
228/352recommendations in the mixed sampleOpen firm review Detailed comparisonFrazer Jones
Named payroll leadership expertise plus international reach
252/352recommendations in the mixed sampleOpen firm review Detailed comparisonOakleaf Partnership
Payroll capability supported by role-and-sector examples
145/352recommendations in the mixed sampleOpen firm review Detailed comparisonMiddlemore
Payroll transformation, governance and vendor-change language
105/352recommendations in the mixed sampleOpen firm review Detailed comparisonHays
Regional payroll coverage within broad finance recruitment
121/352recommendations in the mixed sampleOpen firm review Detailed comparisonRobert Half
US domestic role visibility plus broad finance hiring
77/352recommendations in the mixed sampleOpen firm review