S07-A / Observation 1

Claude
JGA recommended.

The full saved answer, its sources and the conditions under which it was collected.

Recorded
2026-10-19 21:08:14.873 UTC
Collection
London, UK
Access
Dedicated signed-in / Free
Visible model label
Sonnet 5.5 Medium
Chat mode
Incognito; Manual; default Medium
Answer ID
S07-A-claude-r1

Exact question

Our Payroll Manager has resigned. We are a medium-sized UK employer and need a permanent replacement to run our UK payroll. Which recruitment agencies should we speak to?

Full answer

Save answer text

Original wording is preserved. Statements below are generated product output, not verified claims adopted by this report.

Four specialist agencies come up in UK payroll recruitment. Most of this comes from the CIPP (Chartered Institute of Payroll Professionals) magazine’s agency directory, with the latest listing I found dated February 2024, so check each is still trading and handling permanent payroll roles before you engage.

Specialist payroll agencies

• Portfolio Payroll : It describes itself as the longest-established payroll recruitment consultancy in the UK, founded in 1988, and focuses solely on payroll professionals across all sectors. It offers permanent, temporary and contract recruitment at all levels, with separate executive and public sector divisions. Its own listing gives 020 7247 9455 and [recruitment@portfoliopayroll.com](mailto:recruitment@portfoliopayroll.com) . [flippingbook](https://online.flippingbook.com/view/436939326/57) [flippingbook](https://online.flippingbook.com/view/436939326/57)

• James Gray Associates (JGA) : It specialises in payroll, HR and reward, supplying permanent, contract and interim professionals, and has offered CIPP members 20% off standard terms. It won Best Small Permanent Agency at the RDLC Awards in 2020. Its website lists Payroll Manager among the roles it recruits for. The 20% discount applies to CIPP members, so ask whether your company or you qualify. [Professional February 2024 +2](https://online.flippingbook.com/view/436939326/57)

• Hays Payroll Management : It recruits across a range of UK industries and specialises in placing payroll professionals. It’s a large, established recruiter, which may suit you if you want a broader candidate reach. [flippingbook](https://online.flippingbook.com/view/436939326/57)

• Payroll Elite : It offers permanent and contract recruitment, pre-selecting candidates to match client requirements. It only appeared in the older 2018–2019 directory listings, so confirm it is still operating. [flippingbook](https://online.flippingbook.com/view/790570/53/)

Tips for the search

• Speak to two or three agencies rather than one, and ask each for sample payroll manager placements at companies of your size. Compare fee percentages, rebate periods if the hire leaves early, and whether they hold a candidate pool of their own or just advertise.

• Be clear about your payroll software (e.g. Sage, ADP, Staffology), headcount, pay frequencies, and whether the role is hands-on or mainly supervisory. These shape the shortlist more than anything else.

• Check whether candidates hold CIPP qualifications, which are a useful benchmark for a payroll manager.

• Consider interim cover while you recruit. Portfolio Payroll and JGA both place interim and contract staff, which can protect your payroll runs through a notice period and handover.

• Advertising through the CIPP’s own channels, or asking your payroll software supplier and network for referrals, can complement an agency search.

If you tell me your sector, location and rough salary band, I can help you draft a brief for the agencies or a job specification.

How we classified this answer

Second unnumbered specialist bullet, with no explicit ordinal ranking. Model broadly advises checking whether listed agencies are still trading and handling permanent roles.

Recommendations, passing mentions and source-only appearances are counted separately. A list position is recorded only when explicit.

JGA names and entity evidence

JGA names in this answer: JGA, James Gray Associates. JGA websites linked: jgarecruitment.com. Counts track the recruitment brand. Source domains and collection country do not alone establish which legal entity a recommendation refers to.

Supporting citations

Complete source record
  • flippingbook.com

    flippingbook

    Portfolio Payroll : It describes itself as the longest-established payroll recruitment consultancy in the UK, founded in 1988, and focuses solely on payroll professionals across all sectors. It offers permanent, temporary and contract recruitment at all levels, with separate executive and public sector divisions. Its own listing gives 020 7247 9455 and recruitment@portfoliopayroll.com.

    https://online.flippingbook.com/view/436939326/57

  • flippingbook.com

    Professional February 2024 +2

    James Gray Associates (JGA) : It specialises in payroll, HR and reward, supplying permanent, contract and interim professionals, and has offered CIPP members 20% off standard terms. It won Best Small Permanent Agency at the RDLC Awards in 2020. Its website lists Payroll Manager among the roles it recruits for. The 20% discount applies to CIPP members, so ask whether your company or you qualify.

    https://online.flippingbook.com/view/436939326/57

  • flippingbook.com

    flippingbook

    Payroll Elite : It offers permanent and contract recruitment, pre-selecting candidates to match client requirements. It only appeared in the older 2018–2019 directory listings, so confirm it is still operating.

    https://online.flippingbook.com/view/790570/53/

  • jgarecruitment.com

    Payroll Implementation Jobs jgarecruitment

    JGA specialist permanent/contract/interim recruitment, historical CIPP terms and Payroll Manager coverage

    https://jgarecruitment.com/?p=413823

Saved evidence

This page preserves the complete saved wording, original question, recorded date and actual access conditions. The research pack includes a dated HTML export, the exact original answer text and its SHA-256 hash for every answer.

The exports preserve the saved text and original capture date. Source status is shown with each answer; the method explains coverage and the collection conditions.

Download this record Open the complete research pack