Detailed comparison

Hays

Regional payroll coverage within broad finance recruitment

120/320

UK recommendations

1/32

US recommendations

Where the firm fits

A strong ordinary UK Payroll Manager replacement comparator. Its broader finance reach is relevant to regional hiring, but not automatically to every global executive mandate.

What its public pages show

Separate employer finance and candidate payroll pages specify payroll roles, UK coverage and permanent/interim/contract recruitment. The employer page also covers finance transformation.

What the evidence does not establish

General payroll job pages and old directory entries do not independently establish current consultant strength, availability or completed global-head placements. Candidate-facing copy is not itself a buyer case study.

What this means for JGA

JGA should make regional operational hiring easy to understand, including location, working pattern and required payroll-system experience, then connect that scope to an employer enquiry.

A practical next move

Improve the permanent-hire brief and regional internal links, with dated role examples rather than repeated city-keyword pages alone.

Historic Hays Payroll Management directory wording remains historical evidence, not a current guarantee.

Public pages inspected

Separate public research, not necessarily pages cited by the models.

Coverage by situation

Read the chart as a table
Hays recommendation coverage by situation
CategoryAnswers
First global payroll leader9 of 32
Confidential leadership replacement4 of 32
US employer hires a US Payroll Director1 of 32
Payroll systems transformation9 of 32
Post-acquisition payroll integration12 of 32
Leadership after control failures9 of 32
UK Payroll Manager replacement25 of 32
US parent appoints a UK EMEA leader9 of 32
Payroll provider transition18 of 32
Interim cover and permanent succession9 of 32
Small UK team adds a Senior Payroll Specialist16 of 32